Alternative World War II—In Cinema

I am always intrigued by “What if ?” scenarios, like what if Columbus had taken another route to India? Or what if JFK had not been in Dallas that day?

What intrigues me most of all is the question, “What if the Nazis would have won the war?” or alternatively “What if Hitler would have been killed sooner?” I am not the only one who ponders these questions. There have been many authors and filmmakers who had the same idea and put those ideas on paper and in film. I am only selecting a few for this blog.

The picture above is from the 1965 film “It Happened Here.”

It is the Second World War. The Nazis invaded Britain. There is a split between the resistance and those who prefer to collaborate with the invaders for a quiet life. The protagonist, a nurse, is caught in the middle. Following the British army’s retreat at Dunkirk, England has been invaded and conquered by Nazi Germany. Irish nurse Barbara Murray comes to London as part of a civilian evacuation forced by American resistance forces massing off the coast of Ireland. She finds that in order to get a job as a nurse her only choice is to join the pro-Nazi civilian organization known as Immediate Action, which she does even though she is avowedly non-political. However, once on the job, she is faced with complicity in a number of disturbing acts being conducted by Immediate Action.

“Fatherland” is a 1994 TV film written by Stanley Weiser and Ron Hutchinson and directed by Christopher Menaul as an adaptation of the 1992 novel of the same title by Robert Harris. The film was produced by HBO and starred Rutger Hauer and Miranda Richardson.

In a world where the Nazis won World War II, Germany corralled all European countries into a single state called “Germania” and continues fighting against the Soviet Union. It is now 1964 and Germany’s war crimes against the Jews have so far been kept a secret. Germany believes that an alliance with the United States would finally beat the Soviet war machine. As his 75th birthday approached, Adolf Hitler wants to talk about peace with President Joseph Kennedy. An S.S. homicide detective and an American journalist stumble into a plot to destroy all evidence of the genocide; evidence that could destroy the peace process with America and evidence that Nazi and S.S. leaders will stop at nothing to keep hidden.

“Inglourious Basterds” is a 2009 war film written and directed by Quentin Tarantino, starring Brad Pitt, Christoph Waltz, Michael Fassbender, Eli Roth, Diane Kruger, Daniel Brühl, Til Schweiger and Mélanie Laurent. The film tells an alternate history story of two plots to assassinate Nazi Germany’s leadership—one planned by Shosanna Dreyfus, a young French Jewish cinema proprietor, and the other by the British but ultimately conducted solely by a team of Jewish American soldiers led by First Lieutenant Aldo Raine. Christoph Waltz co-stars in the role of Hans Landa, an SS colonel in charge of tracking down Raine’s group.

“Strange Holiday” is a 1945 American movie directed by Arch Oboler. Claude Rains is featured as a man who returns from a fishing vacation to find America controlled by fascists. Businessman John Stevenson returns from a camping holiday in the mountains to discover the whole of America has been taken over by foreign invaders. His family has been taken away and he is thrown into prison and must come to terms with the new USA.

So if you are ever bored I would recommend you look up these movies and watch them.

sources

https://www.imdb.com/title/tt0038125/?ref_=tt_mv_close

https://www.imdb.com/title/tt0361748/?ref_=tt_mv_close

https://www.imdb.com/title/tt0109779/

https://www.imdb.com/title/tt0055024/

What if? An Alternative Anne Frank and Margot Frank Story

anne-frank-quotes3

This post is totally fictional, with a few historical facts. I often wonder what Anne and Margot Frank’s story would have looked like if the path of History had gone even the slightest different direction. Below are fictional diary entries of Anne and Margot Frank, but they could have been reality.

Margot Frank: 12 September 1933, age 6.5.

Today we found a new house in a different part of Germany. I think the place is called Aachen. I don’t really like it—but Anne will have a lot of fun.

667e9ce389e63fd76c8c2fce2d32b907

Mommy told me that we would be moving again soon. We are going to a different country. I am a bit confused. Mommy calls it Holland, but the teacher says it is the Netherlands. Daddy has a new job there.

He said that Germany has a new boss named Hitler, and he is not a very nice man. It is a bit strange because he is not German.

Margot Frank: 16 February 1934: Age 7.

It is my birthday today, and we have just moved into our new house. Mom and Dad call it a flat—but it looks like a house to me.

AnneFrankMerwedeplein

Oh yeah, I know now that the country is called the Netherlands. We are living in Amsterdam on the Merwedeplein. The Amsterdam people don’t mind if you call it Holland. Anne has gone to a play school, and I am going to a new school, the children are all very nice—but they sometimes look a bit funny to me.

AFS_A_AFrank_III_055_071

Margot Frank: June 15 1934: Age 7.5.

Daddy showed me a picture in the newspaper of this man Hitler. He had gone on holiday to Italy, where he met a man with no hair and a funny hat.

c6a9f5b09cb13df2eea594377c4fc870_three_column

Margot Frank: 10 November 1938: Age 12,

Today, I am sad. My friend Hannah got hurt in Berlin. The Nazis burned synagogues and destroyed houses and shops of Jewish people. Why do the Germans allow this? Don’t they see that is evil?

Anne Frank: 13 March 1938: age 9 (nearly 10).

Daddy was very angry today. He read something in a newspaper about Austria. Hitler and the Nazis went to Austria and made it a part o Germany. No one seemed to mind. I don’t know why Daddy is so angry. If the Austrian people are okay with it—surely there is no problem, or is there?

Anschluss Österreich, Wien

Anne Frank: 12 June 1939: age 10.

Happy birthday to me, happy birthday to me. 10 today—double digits. I am having a party after school with all my friends. We will have cakes and sweets, and hopefully, I will get a lot of presents.

AFS_A_AFrank_III_055_089

Anne Frank: 2 September 1939: age 10.

Germany invaded Poland yesterday, and the English Prime Minister said that this was war.

Neville_chamberlain1921

Anne Frank: 9 November 1939: age 10.

I am a bit upset today. Daddy said that we may be going back to Germany. He thinks everything will be okay now since Hitler was killed by this man Georg Elser. Yesterday, a put a bomb in a beer hall where Hitler was, and the bomb exploded killing Hitler and another guy called Himmler. This means the war is over.

ShowImage

Anne Frank: 4 December 1939: age 10.

Daddy has said we are staying in Amsterdam, that is great. All the kids in my school are celebrating something called Sinterklaas, which is like Christmas. I told them I don’t celebrate Christmas because I am Jewish, but Mommy said that it was okay. So I will put my shoe in front of the fireplace tonight, and Sinterklaas will bring me presents.

Anne Frank: 1 January 1943: age 13. (nearly 14).

I met a boy today. He is called Peter, and he is very, very nice. I think I am going to marry him. Miss Anne van Pels, I like the sound of that.
Peter_van_Pels_2014-05-28_00-43

Margot Frank: 25 November 1952: age 25.

Anne and Peter are getting married today. I am so excited for them.

quote-times-change-people-change-thoughts-about-good-and-evil-change-about-true-and-false-margot-frank-73-31-67

Donation

I am passionate about my site and I know you all like reading my blogs. I have been doing this at no cost and will continue to do so. All I ask is for a voluntary donation of $2, however if you are not in a position to do so I can fully understand, maybe next time then. Thank you. To donate click on the credit/debit card icon of the card you will use. If you want to donate more then $2 just add a higher number in the box left from the PayPal link. Many thanks.

$2.00